Screening Log

This new site feature is a collective effort to summarize our viewing habits. Occasionally, you will find titles here that are coming to a theater near you, in addition to films viewed on television, and even films viewed in piecemeal. The screening log is archived each month; to view past entries select a month in the menu below.


August 2007 activity

Total Log Entries: 52

Total Comments: 35


Full Archive


Advertisements



Holiday / USA / 1938

Holiday shares much with The Philadelphia Story: director George Cukor, stars Grant and Hepburn, playwright Philip Barry, screenwriter David Ogden Stewart, and a Depression-era story of social climbing, featuring an average joe among the inordinately rich. Of course, Cary Grant is nobody’s average joe and Hepburn’s heroine, while as idiosyncratic as her similar character in The Philadelphia Story, is more fragile than frosty. This last is one of the film’s most daring aspects: a portrait of a wealthy socialite with girlish eccentricities that veer close to the edge of a crippling neurosis, and Hepburn plays this character with a fascinating combination of bristling frivolity and heartbreaking, almost childlike sensitivity. Against Hepburn’s fascinating, unstable performance, Grant’s charming, hard-working dreamer attains a strangely philosophical depth. His seeming idealism about giving up the chance to earn lots of money alongside his future father-in-law becomes nothing short of a search for the meaning and purpose of work, money, and romantic partnership.

In retrospect, all of this may seem like the most shallow kind of Depression-era Hollywood mythmaking, extolling the virtues of love over money at a time when the latter was, for many, hard to come by. But in the hands of Cukor & Co., this fantasy sheds its homespun hokeyness to become a slightly scathing indictment of the values of the extremely wealthy, and Grant’s romantic and professional dynamism is its own kind of New Deal, reviving middle class implacability and prompting Hepburn’s coddled and cosseted socialite to grow up into self-responsibility.

Like Philadelphia, Holiday blends fairy tale, slapstick, social conscious, and family drama into a very curious mix, and so it’s a film that seemingly doesn’t know (or else refuses to choose) what kind of film it wants to be. And this is fitting: the refusal of this kind of rigidity is precisely what these characters are looking for.

Rich’s review

See also: Matt, Ian, and me on The Philadelphia Story

by Leo Goldsmith | Source: Columbia/TriStar DVD
03 Aug 2007 5:17 PM | Submit Comment


Submit Comment

Please note that your email address will never be displayed on this page.

HTML is enabled; line breaks (<br />) and paragraphs (<p>) are automatically converted. Apostrophes, ellipses, em- and en-dashes, and quotes are also automatically formatted.